Reuben Saltzman

Whole-House Humidifiers Harm Houses (still)

Whole-house humidifiers are at the root of many of the most serious moisture problems in Minnesota homes. If you decide to use a whole-house humidifier in your home, be warned: it’s easy to cause major damage to your home. Last winter we had an unusually long cold-spell, and a lot of Minnesotans ended up with major water damage in the attics from frost accumulation. I personally investigated a lot of these, and I’ll bet you can guess what I found.

I first blogged about this topic nearly ten years ago, and nothing has really changed. Whole-house humidifiers continue to cause major damage to Minnesota homes, and HVAC salespeople continue to sell them. This is certainly a divisive topic; I was recently involved in a discussion with another home inspector who insisted that humidifiers are fine.

Here’s a video discussion of the rest of this post: https://youtu.be/pGPF0fqZEWM

The good

First, let’s take a look at the claimed benefits of whole-house humidifiers, which I’m taking right from Aprilaire’s website.

Health: Adequate humidity supposedly reduces respiratory infections and symptoms related to allergies and asthma. That all sounds good to me. I’m not qualified to comment on any of this stuff, but I believe it. When my house is very dry, my sinuses definitely aren’t right.

Comfort: There’s no debating that. Dry, cracked skin is no fun.

Preserve wood: Hardwood floors are sensitive to humidity levels, and so are other things such as wood furniture and cabinets. If your home is too dry, you could end up with cracks and warping. There’s no debating that.

In short, humidifiers can definitely do some good things for both your home and health… provided you use the humidifier properly.

The bad:

Damage caused by whole-house humidifiers frequently outweighs the benefits. I’ve seen too many frost-covered attics, mold-covered attics, ruined ceilings, and ruined windows to think anything else. In every one of these cases, there’s a whole-house humidifier at work. Take a look at some of the images below for examples of what I’m talking about:

Moisture at window

Water damaged window

Frosty attic

Frost in Attic 3

Manual Humidifiers

I’m not a total doom-sayer when it comes to whole-house humidifiers. There are actually two types of humidifiers available; manual and automatic. Manual humidifiers are dumb, and probably ought to be banned. The problem is that the colder it gets outside, the less humidity your Minnesota home can tolerate. Here’s what the folks at Aprilaire recommend, which all sounds good to me:

Humidity Guide

Humidity levels around 30% and up are comfortable enough, but things start to feel really dry below that. The average Minnesota homeowner has no chance of following the instructions that come from the manufacturer. To maintain the proper level of humidity, you need to know what the temperature is going to be, and then adjust the settings on the humidifier accordingly to match that chart. I kid you not. Here’s an excerpt from the owner’s manual:

“it is important to anticipate a drop in outdoor temperature and reduce the setting accordingly to avoid excessive condensation. For example, with an outdoor temperature of 20°F the correct setting will be 35% RH. If the temperature is expected to fall to 0°F, then merely reduce the setting to 25% several hours prior to the temperature change.”

I know they’re not trying to be funny, but that’s funny. Nobody does this, and nobody should be expected to do this. The consequences of not doing this are the conditions that I showed in the photos above. This is my beef with whole-house humidifiers.

My recommendation is usually to not use manual whole-house humidifiers unless you’re an extremely ‘type A’ homeowner, which means you’ll check the weather forecast and adjust your humidifier all the time.

Automatic Humidifiers

Automatic humidifiers are designed to do exactly what you think; they stop adding humidity to the indoor air when the outdoor temperature drops. This is done through an outdoor temperature sensor and a smart controller. All good stuff.

Humidifier installation diagram

I have no problem with these units, provided they’re installed properly and operated in automatic mode.

Unfortunately, many of these units are installed without the outdoor temperature sensor, and the installer simply switches the operation mode from automatic to manual. There’s a little switch that’s hidden behind the control panel cover for this.

Manual humidifier control switch

There are some clear labor savings involved with this installation. I’m not going to speculate as to why or how this happens, but I know it happens.

Conclusion

If you have a manual humidifier, either turn it off or be sure to obtain, read, and carefully follow the manufacturer’s instructions. If you simply set your humidifier to a “judicious” middle setting and keep your fingers crossed, you’re going to have moisture problems.

If you have an automatic humidifier, make sure it’s installed to operate in automatic mode. There needs to be a temperature sensor installed outside the house, and the unit needs to be set to automatic mode.

If you’re going to have a whole-house humidifier installed, go automatic and make sure it’s fully/properly installed.

Author: Reuben SaltzmanStructure Tech Home Inspections

Subscribe button

No responses to “Whole-House Humidifiers Harm Houses (still)”

  1. Duane Erstad
    November 27, 2018, 7:57 am

    Our automatic Aprilaire installed a couple years ago continues to do what it is supposed to do; I check it with multiple hygrometers. It really works. I still need to use a piano humidifier and a “bottom cover” on our seven-foot grand piano to keep it always about 45%.

    The real culprit in our case is a house from the 1980s. It didn’t need to be built as it is. Great view of downtown Rochester, MN, but irregularly insulated and stuck with heating ducts in the slab of our main living area.

    Another complaint: virtually everything everyone builds today, ignoring what could be done to make an efficient house. Therefore we’re stuck having to design and build something ourselves to avoid foolish problems.

    This deserves condemnation far more than lampooning automatic dehumidifiers with faint praise.

  2. Larry Witort
    November 29, 2018, 6:46 pm

    Always find your posts interesting.

    This one was timely also. Just today installed a new Lennox Furnace and wanted to install a humidifier also. I know that there are problems with many humidifiers but with the dry skin and sinus issues, I really felt we need one. So your blog post was timely and scary.

    With the techs here to install the package, I asked about the automatic mode and the need for a remote sensor outside. (I never knew about this before your blog.) Their response was that they had also installed a Lennox Wi-Fi thermostat that uses the internet to know the outside temp and uses that to regulate the humidifier in automatic mode.

    It is a brand new unit and we will see over this winter how that works out.

    Thanks again for the education.

  3. Jim Vaughn
    November 29, 2018, 8:17 pm

    How about air sealing the attic floor? That would keep most of that warm, moisture laden air from getting to the attic.

    Even though the Mid-Atlantic states don’t have the severe weather you get there, I still urge clients to air seal the floor.

  4. Vickie Swenson
    November 30, 2018, 8:38 am

    Putting constant moisture into duct work that has not been cleaned for several years (not every house has clean HVAC ducts) can cause mold to grow on the dust in the ductwork.

    Some building scientists have called the whole house humidifiers the ‘worst invention ever’.

  5. Rob macdonald
    December 11, 2018, 3:16 am

    I have an Aprilaire installed that is in manual mode I live in Canada so winters are cold and dry. I agree that it needs to adjusted constantly but find is well worth the benefits. Suggest to put the display beside your thermostat which makes it more convenient. In my case if I have too much humidity my windows will sweat so they act as the sentinel. My attic floor has also been poyyrethaned.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a Reply