COVID-19 Update: Structure Tech Home Inspections is still open for business. To see what we’re doing to help keep everyone safe, please see COVID-19 and Home Inspections.

Reuben Saltzman

Attic Insulation Methods

What’s the best way to insulate your attic? I started out last week’s blog post with that question and never got around to the answer. By the time I was finished with that post, I realized that I had two different topics to cover; insulation types and insulation methods. Last week’s post was about insulation types, this week’s post is about insulation methods.

The Gold Standard

For a traditional attic, there is no need to use foam insulation throughout the entire space, as you’ll get the most value out of the first couple inches.  A cost-effective way to use foam insulation is to foam the lid of the house, then use loose-fill insulation on top.  This means installing closed-cell spray foam to a depth of at least 2″ on the entire attic floor to completely seal everything up and create a vapor barrier.  After the foam has cured, loose fill fiberglass or cellulose insulation gets installed on top of the foam. My preference is cellulose, but either is acceptable.

On an older home with only a few inches of space between the tops of the outer walls and the roof, there won’t be much room for insulation here. Extra spray foam needs to be installed in this area to help compensate for the lack of space. See my blog post on this topic for more info: Poorly insulated eaves at old houses. The illustration below, provided by the Minnesota Department of Commerce, Division of Energy Resources, shows what this method looks like.

Foam insulation at eaves

As I mentioned in last week’s blog post, the minimum insulation value in an attic for new construction here in Minnesota is R-49. How many inches of insulation is that? Who knows. Different manufacturers of insulation have different R-values. Just check out the examples below from different manufacturers of loose-fill fiberglass insulation:

Different insulation types

The Silver Standard

This is typically the most cost-effective option for homeowners and is the most common recommendation from insulation contractors. This requires major attic preparation before installing insulation. The insulation contractor must seal up all attic bypasses before adding insulation.  Foam-in-a-can is great stuff for most smaller attic bypasses, but watch out for gas vents; they require 1″ clearance to combustibles such as spray foam.

Insulated boxes must be constructed for any recessed lights because they contribute a ton of heat to the attic and they’re leaky. Even the “airtight” recessed lights are anything but. Just check out the recessed light below. You’d think there was a missing gasket or something, but no. That’s just how it comes.

not very air-tight recessed light

If you don’t like the idea of making your own boxes, you could also purchase pre-made recessed light covers, such as those made by CanCoverIt. I recently used a bunch of those on a recessed light project in my own attic, and they were very easy to use.

If it’s an older home where the rafters or trusses only leave a few inches for insulation at the outer walls, do what I showed above with spray foam at the eaves.  Of course, don’t forget to install baffles at the eaves to prevent your soffit vents from getting blocked.

After everything has been prepped, it’s time to insulate. Fiberglass or cellulose insulation are typically what get used.

The Bronze Standard

Have an insulation contractor seal up the most obvious attic bypasses; plumbing vents, recessed lights, furnace vent, chimney, etc. Once that’s done, have cellulose insulation added to the attic. Cellulose does a good job of controlling condensation in the attic and it’s a fairly dense product, so it will cut down on air movement from attic bypasses, but won’t completely eliminate them.

The Brown Standard

Roll out a bunch of fiberglass batts, proudly proclaim “done and done”, and stay the heck away from my kids.

Author: Reuben SaltzmanStructure Tech Home Inspections

Subscribe button

No responses to “Attic Insulation Methods”

  1. Steve
    February 6, 2018, 4:45 pm

    Interesting. I also looked at the archived article you linked.

    Any suggestions on an old home (1911 construction) that doesn’t really allow for air flow? I’ve got a lot of wall that faces south with no shade so in the summer, the upstairs really heats up, not so much in the winter.

  2. Kathryn Larson
    February 13, 2018, 8:51 am

    What recessed lights can you recommend to prevent air leaks or what’s the best process to seal any recessed lights that are existing creating air leaks to the Attic

  3. Reuben Saltzman
    February 13, 2018, 9:47 am

    Hi Kathryn,

    For recessed light recommendations, I think they all leak. Whatever brand that Home Depot sells seemed to be a bit better than the one I pictured in this blog.

    As for sealing them, home-made boxes are good: . The covers made by CanCoverIt that I linked to in this post are good too. They have an installation video right on their home page. Check it out:

  4. Jim Moechnig
    February 16, 2018, 2:12 pm

    I installed some can lights a few years back. I used shower-rated lights, which seemed to seal up pretty well on the interior surface, and hosed down the attic side with Great Stuff or something similar.

    Is some future home owner going to regret that installation? If so, why and what would have been better?

  5. Reuben Saltzman
    February 16, 2018, 2:39 pm

    I don’t think you’re supposed to put the foam insulation right up against the lights. A recessed box or something like that would have been better. If you’re using incandescent bulbs, the fixture might overhead. If you’re using LED bulbs, the only drawback that I can think of is that it’ll be a pain in the butt for someone to remove the light.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a Reply